Damaged Goods, Buyer Beware

By dtb23

Q: What’s more frustrating than wasting a draft pick on an under performing player? 

A: Using that same pick on a player who is physically unable to take the field.

Injuries are a critical aspect of every fantasy league and can strongly influence a team’s position in the standings.  Every owner needs to take this into account when they are preparing for the draft as well as managing their team throughout the season. 

Freak injuries happen every year, like when Utley broke his hand when he was hit by a pitch.  All you can do in this instance is do what the Phillies did. Find the best replacement you can and try to tread water while you wait for your fantasy stud to return. 

Other injuries are more predictable.  Certain players have a higher risk of missing time than others.  The best way to avoid drafting damaged goods is to monitor your fantasy sources and check out the readily available injury reports.  Here are some players you may want to avoid on draft day or at least move them down a few spots on your draft board;

C – Jorge Posada – Jorge is recovering from rotator cuff surgery on his throwing arm. His status for opening day is uncertain but the 37 year old catcher is on the decline and his days as a top tier fantasy catcher are over.
1B – Nick Johnson – Larry Bowa’s nephew is a great contact hitter but he has only recorded 500 at bats once in his career. He is currently recovering from surgery on his wrist.
2B – Chase Utley – The Phil’s GM, Ruben Amaro Jr, is so pleased with Utley’s speed of recovery that he has publicly stated Chase may be able to play in a few spring training games. If Chase continues his current pace it should be safe to draft him as the #1 second baseman in all of baseball.
SS- Rafael Furcal – Back issues are scary because there is no telling when there may be a reoccurrence. The prospect is even worse for a player who relies so heavily on his speed.
3B – Eric Chavez – Too many injuries to list. This player should not be drafted in any league.
OF – Carlos Quentin – Wrist injuries can be devastating to a power hitter. Expect his numbers to suffer until he regains full confidence in his surgically repaired wrist.
OF – Gary Matthews Jr – The OF will definitely start the year on the DL and will most likely miss up to 8 weeks to start the year.
OF – Milton Bradley – It’s too bad this guy can’t stay healthy. He is coming off of a career year and now that he is wearing a Cubs uniform could mean even better numbers across the board. The fact that he has already missed games due to injuries does not sit well.



Filed under Injuries

4 responses to “Damaged Goods, Buyer Beware

  1. nichols33

    How can you not include Rich Harden? He showed just enough last year to get some knucklehead (imagine Charles Barkley saying that) to draft him as his #2 or #3 SP.

    Some other names that will most certainly show up on the DL this year:
    Ken Griffey Jr.
    Travis Hafner
    Gary Sheffield
    Hank Blalock
    Chipper Jones

    • mrcane

      I think we are all forgetting about the very talented Mr. Kinsler. No doubt one of the most talented players at his position in the game but has battled injuries since coming into the league. Would this keep me from drafting him? No. Would it make me pay close attention to where I draft him, absolutely. Some players for whatever reason are like magnets to injuries for physiological reasons that we as fantasy players can’t explain.

      Other players I might include as injury risks are:

      Joe Mauer due to the demands of catcher and his past injury problems. Overrated in my book.

      Shane Victorino has had leg problems the past two years but has stolen 73 bases in the process.

      Troy Tulowitzki is coming back from a devastating injury.

      Yovanni Gallardo is rehabbing from torn ACL.

      Joba Chamberlain who has been injured at all levels when asked to be a starter.

      These are just some food for thought on highly regarded players who might break your heart in the end. Depending on what position you draft the players, you might be paying too steep a price.

  2. tallkid1

    Injuries can hurt all positions but it really affects starting pitchers.

    Consider this list of pitchers who either currently have or have had some kind of injury in the past year: Josh Beckett (back/oblique), Roy Oswalt (groin/hip/back), Jake Peavy (elbow), John Lackey (elbow), Jared Weaver (shoulder), Aaron Harang (forearm), Rich Harden, Ching Meng Wang (foot), Fausto Carmona (hip), Carlos Zambrano (shoulder) and Scott Kazmir (elbow). That’s realy just the beginning of te pitcher list and it proves how unreliable starters can be.

    • JimJBullock

      Great post!

      I think one thing to consider is the player’s injury itself. Carmona, for example, has never had any problems with his arm, so he is a good buy low candidate this season. Remember, he was dominant in 2007, so the talent is definitely there. Wang is another example of someone who has a good shot at bouncing back. I think that sometimes injuries can scare people away, so you might be able to grab a guy 4-5 rounds later than usual as a result.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s